Kerala High Court Upholds Housing Board’s Right to Recover Housing Loans via Revenue Recovery

Get the full picture - access the original judgement of the court order here

Case Name

K. Surendran & Ors. v. State of Kerala & Ors. (High Court of Kerala)

WP(C)No. 30610 of 2013 with connected cases WP(C)No. 1830/2014 and WP(C) No. 3301/2014

Date: 11th March 2024

Key Takeaways

• Kerala State Housing Board (KSHB) can grant housing loans under government-sanctioned schemes as per Section 41(2) of the Kerala State Housing Board Act, 1971.
• Recovery of unpaid loans via the Kerala Revenue Recovery Act, 1968 is valid; there is no legal restriction that only “development project” loans can be recovered this way.
• The Housing Board is not a bank or non-banking financial institution under the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 or the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934, so those acts do not restrict its lending powers.
• Petitioners who have not settled their dues can approach the Board for installment payments or a one-time settlement, and the Board should consider waiving interest for the period the case was pending.
• The court found no grounds to interfere with the recovery proceedings.

Issue

Can the Kerala State Housing Board lawfully grant housing loans and recover unpaid amounts through revenue recovery proceedings, even though it is not a bank or NBFC, and even if the loans are not for “development projects”?

Facts

• Parties: Multiple petitioners (individuals who took housing loans) vs. State of Kerala, Kerala State Housing Board, and related officials.
• Background: The petitioners took loans from the KSHB for constructing residential buildings. When they defaulted, the Board initiated revenue recovery proceedings to collect the dues.
• Petitioners’ Claims:

1. The Housing Board is not authorized by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) to give such loans.
2. Revenue recovery can only be used for loans given for “development projects” for socially and economically backward classes, not for general housing loans.

• Timeline: The cases have been pending since 2013/2014, with some petitioners settling their dues during the litigation.

Arguments

Petitioners

• Lack of Authority: The KSHB is not a bank or NBFC, so it cannot legally lend money for housing construction.
• Improper Recovery: Revenue recovery proceedings are only allowed for loans given for “development projects,” not for general housing loans.
• RBI Restrictions: Lending for housing by the Board is not permitted by the Reserve Bank of India.

Respondents (State & Housing Board)

• Statutory Power: The KSHB is a statutory body under the Kerala State Housing Board Act, 1971, and is empowered to undertake housing schemes, including lending for housing, with government approval (Section 41(2)).
• No Restriction in Law: SRO No. 311/76 (issued under Section 71 of the Kerala Revenue Recovery Act, 1968) allows recovery of all amounts due to the Housing Board, not just those for “development projects.”
• Not a Bank/NBFC: The Board is not a banking institution, so the Banking Regulation Act and RBI Act do not apply to its lending activities.

Key Legal Precedents & Statutory References

• Kerala State Housing Board Act, 1971
• Section 41(2): Allows the Board to frame and implement housing or improvement schemes, including loan disbursement, with government approval.
• Kerala Revenue Recovery Act, 1968
• Section 71: Empowers the government to authorize recovery of certain dues as arrears of land revenue.
• SRO No. 311/76: Government notification authorizing recovery of all amounts due to the Housing Board under the Revenue Recovery Act, without limiting it to “development projects.”
• Banking Regulation Act, 1949 & Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934: The court clarified these do not apply to the Housing Board, as it is not a bank or NBFC.

Note: The judgment does not cite any previous case law by name; it relies on statutory interpretation and government notifications.

Judgement

• Decision: The High Court dismissed the petitions, upholding the Housing Board’s right to recover unpaid housing loans through revenue recovery proceedings.
• Reasoning:
• The Board’s lending was under government-sanctioned schemes as per Section 41(2) of the Kerala State Housing Board Act, 1971.
• There is no legal restriction in SRO No. 311/76 or the Revenue Recovery Act limiting recovery to “development project” loans.
• The Board is not a bank or NBFC, so the Banking Regulation Act and RBI Act do not restrict its activities.
• Petitioners had availed and benefited from the loans, so they cannot now challenge the Board’s authority to recover dues.
• Orders:
• Petitioners who have not settled their dues can approach the Board for installment payments or a one-time settlement within two weeks.
• The Board should consider waiving interest for the period the case was pending.
• If dues are not settled, the Board and revenue authorities can continue recovery proceedings.

FAQs

Q1: Can the Kerala State Housing Board give housing loans?

A: Yes, as long as the loans are given under government-approved schemes as per Section 41(2) of the Kerala State Housing Board Act, 1971.

Q2: Is the Housing Board a bank or NBFC?

A: No, it is a statutory body, not a bank or non-banking financial company, so the Banking Regulation Act and RBI Act do not apply.

Q3: Can the Board use revenue recovery to collect unpaid loans?

A: Yes, SRO No. 311/76 authorizes the Board to recover all dues (not just “development project” loans) under the Kerala Revenue Recovery Act, 1968.

Q4: What if a borrower wants to settle dues now?

A: The court allowed petitioners who haven’t settled to approach the Board for installment payments or a one-time settlement, and the Board should consider waiving interest for the period the case was pending.

Q5: Did the court find any fault with the Board’s actions?

A: No, the court found the Board acted within its legal powers and dismissed the petitions.